hawking says creation godless, page-105

Sarco

I can only respond by saying I have ignored your advice. Your advice does not have merits in the sphere of scientific & rational inquiry.

I was not "projecting" anything. I critically responded, using reasoning, to the views posted by Clubsharer, on matters that do not fall into the sphere of religion.

I provided a scientific definition of what instincts are from the Wikipedia.

However, in your case, you have not offered clear answers to questions asked of you in relation to the concepts you are using. In fact, you said instincts do not even exist.

The only answer you provided was an evasive "metaphysics" (which is more unscientific unverified philosophy).

Mind does not create matter. Mind is created from matter, from neurons and the like. Mind allows the 'knowing' of matter but mind does not create matter.

To hold mind creates matter is the same as holding 'God' created matter.

Your views about disembodied consciousness, rebirth and good & bad karma demonstrate where you are coming from.

As you said: "a lot of the stuff that i write never makes it to here".

Best wishes