Australia's largest stock trading and investment forum Australia's #1 stock forum

QIN

0.00%

29.5¢ quintis ltd

Host Management and Irrigation, page-46

First 46 Last

Share
Profile

Follow
xindongzuitaohua

4,793 Posts.

90

26/05/17

15:57

Post #: 24935721
Share

Originally posted by SDE ↑

Great Southern collapsed because it had a flawed business model. The model required ongoing annual plantation sales (ie new investors) to support previous plantation projects returns (ie payments to old investors); in effect, a Ponzi scheme arrangement.

The GFC caused the Banks to recall their loans to Great Southern when they fell due, and the final death knell was when the Federal Government removed tax deductibility for MIS plantation investors, essentially stopping any investments in future plantation projects, so no cash flow.

Great Southern’s plantations had never grown anywhere near the predicted yield curve (sound familiar). You have quoted 1/3 of trees died, QIN’s soon to be harvested 2003 crop had mortality which is even worse, ( > 40% of trees planted have died).

To support ongoing plantation sales, Great Southern established a wholly owned subsidiary to buy plantation logs at grossly inflated prices to prop up and achieve predicted yields. QIN’s wholly owned subsidiary, Gulf Natural Supply, pays top dollar to prop up and support yields of QIN’s earlier projects, no doubt to ensure ongoing plantation sales (again, sound familiar). You seem to accept that QIN’s 2003 project will not achieve its initial projected returns.

The Glaucus and Viceroy reports are QIN’s equivalent of the GFC. The net effect is likely to deter investment in future projects (Your words : It came unstuck when finally it could not sell its MIS investments so could not fund its expenses)

Similarily, if QIN’s cashflow from future plantation sales dries up, it will not be able to fund its expenses and it is likely it will go the way of Great Southern.

History has a habit of repeating itself, and those who ignore history are bound to repeat it.

Expand

I have been finding that you are a kind of Hot tuna advanced...

Why you have such a big interest why you not holding?

Why you use a lot "IF" to predict Negative outcomes?

Not Objective and fair as you claimed imo...

QIN Price at posting: 29.5¢ Sentiment: Hold Disclosure: Not Held
4 Upvote

0 Great analysis

Reply

Top Stories

SPR

Spartan sniffs 126g/t gold ahead of resource upgrades at WA's Dalgaranga

PL3

Patagonia looks to raise $2.15M for South American exploration and development

OCC

Orthocell shares jump on record revenues from sales of collagen bone repair devices globally

MSB

Mesoblast resubmits US FDA application for approval of Ryoncil in children with graft vs host disease; shares dip -4%

SRL

Scandium a priority metal for Sunrise as it plans feasibility update at Syerston

There are more pages in this discussion • 67 more messages in this thread...

First 46 Last

Add QIN (ASX) to my watchlist

Host Management and Irrigation, page-46

Top Stories

Spartan sniffs 126g/t gold ahead of resource upgrades at WA's Dalgaranga

Patagonia looks to raise $2.15M for South American exploration and development

Orthocell shares jump on record revenues from sales of collagen bone repair devices globally

Mesoblast resubmits US FDA application for approval of Ryoncil in children with graft vs host disease; shares dip -4%

Scandium a priority metal for Sunrise as it plans feasibility update at Syerston

Featured News