hotcopper, we need your help..., page-33

Drew,

While I agree with some of your comments, I do not agree with the principle of the thumbs up.

Reason being that in the greater majority of cases, some posters don't give the thumb up for the quality of a post, but simply because a poster said what they want to hear, along with a bit of unsabstantiated upramping.

Sentiment, more so that quality, get awarded a thumbs up. As such, (although HC had all good intentions with that principle to begin with), the thumbs up is also a problem now.

Buddy