I’m sure there is a wiz kid who can come up with a graph that...

I’m sure there is a wiz kid who can come up with a graph that displays whether it was the coal price or the amount of BB that held the stock price stable.

Like I said, if the BB pushes the share price up it is simply a paper gain if u don’t sell it.

U basically are confirming that it is the coal price that determines the share price and not the BB which could end up being theoretical nonsense, that simply improves management team of gaining a better reward

Most shareholder’s want concrete returns like a larger dividend, which also emits the message to likely predictors the strength of the company.