I'm new, page-8

So very short sighted. Look at the chart yourself.

This is what I don't agree with. Baseless comments with zero fact to back it up.

If you bought anytime between April/May and sold at end of May. Profit
If you bought and sold anytime watching the darvas box play out recently. Profit. jbr can attest to this.
If you bought in August and sold in September. Profit.
Long termer buying in at highs and continuing to hold. Loss on paper.
Long termer buying in at highs and selling when it went down. Loss
Long termer holding since RYG days when lower. Profit on paper.

Try to remain objective.

Have you asked what type of trader he/she wants to be? Because if day trader or short time holder he could of done well with this share.