Yes, sure these stocks were up from the Oct 23 lows due to the...

Yes, sure these stocks were up from the Oct 23 lows due to the US stock rally.
But you're missing my point. History has shown that if you held them for a long time, the returns aren't that great, especially if one had bought them at the high/peak. Read my post.
Now, these gains you've expressed here would erode once the all time high manic US market crumbles.

If I recall, I won the last debate we had over energy and coal stocks. They didn't go higher unabated. Supply didn't matter. It may in the future.

All exuberance ends.