An English appeals court has given 200,000-plus (now 600k)...

An English appeals court has given 200,000-plus (now 600k) Brazilian litigants the green light to pursue their £5 billion ($8.8 billion) class action against BHP over the 2015 Samarco dam disaster.

..50% sharing is still a big pain, no less.


Update – United Kingdom group action BHP announces that it has entered into an agreement with Vale S.A (Vale) in relation to group action proceedings in the United Kingdom in respect of the Fundão Dam failure in Brazil. The Fundão Dam was owned and operated by Samarco, a non-operated joint venture between BHP Billiton Brasil Ltda (BHP Brasil) (a subsidiary of BHP Group Limited) and Vale. Each of BHP Brasil and Vale holds 50 per cent of Samarco.

BHP Group Limited and BHP Group (UK) Limited (BHP) are defendants to a group action claim in the English High Court, brought by over 600,000 claimants seeking damages in relation to the Fundão Dam failure in 2015 (the English Proceedings).

BHP does not consider that it is liable to the claimants in the English Proceedings and will continue to defend the English Proceedings. BHP believes the English Proceedings are unnecessary because they duplicate matters already covered by the existing and ongoing work of the Renova Foundation and legal proceedings in Brazil.

In March 2024 a new claim was filed against Vale and the Dutch subsidiary of Samarco in the Netherlands on behalf of approximately 78,000 Brazilian claimants for compensation relating to the Fundão Dam failure (the Netherlands Proceedings). BHP is not a defendant in the Netherlands proceedings.

BHP, BHP Brasil and Vale have entered into an agreement for BHP and Vale to each pay 50% of any amounts potentially payable to the claimants in the English Proceedings, the Netherlands Proceedings and other proceedings in Brazil covered by the agreement without any admission of liability for these proceedings. The agreement reinforces the terms of the Framework Agreement entered into in 2016 which require BHP Brasil and Vale to each contribute 50% to the funding of the Renova Foundation for compensation of persons impacted by the Fundão Dam failure where Samarco is unable to contribute that funding.

BHP brought a contribution claim against Vale in December 2022 because the English Proceedings were not brought against Vale. The contribution claim contends that if BHP’s defences are not successful and it is ordered to pay damages to the claimants in the English Proceedings, Vale should contribute to any amount payable. BHP will withdraw the contribution claim against Vale as it is no longer necessary given the agreement with Vale. BHP Brasil remains committed to continue supporting the local remediation efforts in Brazil through the Renova Foundation. Those efforts have already provided approximately US$3.5 billion in compensation and direct financial aid in relation to the dam failure to approximately 430,000 people to 31 May 2024.