Ok,I have some more info on this,This isfrom the Market...

First 22 Last

Martin2017

195 Posts.

27/06/21

18:13

Post #: 54102992

Originally posted by mulgoaman: ↑
Martin, Have a look at the posting thread which followed the ASX announcement on 23/6. The title of the announcement is "Ceasing to be a substantial holder". There appeared to be some confusion with regard to the form as the listing of shares traded was under a column for acquisitions and not disposal. But read through the posts and catch up.

And if you look at the top twenty shareholders given by Chalice (their listing of 24/6) it shows as No. 1 - HSBC Custody Nominees 56.8 million shares, No. 2 is Citicorp 38.7m. and No. 3 is Sir Tim with 37.2 m. So, Goldman Sachs were never near the top with their initial 17.5m acquisitions followed up by disposing 4.4 m. That takes them out of the 5% large investor category but still leaves them with 13 million shares to make mischief with should they decide to dispose of any shares in a fashion that they previously utilised.

MM
Expand
Ok,
I have some more info on this,
This isfrom the Market screener,
https://www.marketscreener.com/quote/stock/CHALICE-MINING-LIMITED-6660668/company/
Thimothy Rupert Barr Goyder
37,198,724
10.8%
1
Franklin Advisers, Inc.
30,102,367
8.70%
2
Regal Funds Management Pty Ltd.
15,411,838
4.46%
3
Invesco Advisers, Inc.
12,931,692
3.74%
4
The Vanguard Group, Inc.
7,415,903
2.14%
5
Aegp Super Pty Ltd.
5,000,000
1.45%
6
Alexander Carl Dorsch
4,341,839
1.26%
7
Vanguard Investments Australia Ltd.
4,036,229
1.17%
8
BlackRock Fund Advisors
3,496,206
1.01%
9
Ilwella Pty Ltd.
2,365,000
0.68%

As you see,there is no HSBC or Citi group in above list,
This isfrom Chalice website on their Capital Structure,
Name
Number of Ordinary shares held
Percentage of capital held %
1
HSBC Custody Nominees
56,869,623
16.40
2
Citicorp Nominees Pty Limited
38,746,279
11.17
3
Mr Timothy R B Goyder
37,197,224
10.72
4
J P Morgan Nominees Australia Pty Limited
28,528,240
8.22
5
National Nominees Limited
8,570,443
2.47
6
CS Third Nominees Pty Limited
8,212,794
2.37
7
BNP Paribas Nominees Pty Ltd ACF Clearstream
6,486,077
1.87

As you see HSBCis there with 16% holding,

Below is from Yahoo finance, showing Goldman with 7% the second one,
1
10.72%
Timothy Rupert Goyder
37,198,724
A4.2m
0.01%
no data
2
6.33%
Goldman Sachs Group, Investment Banking and Securities Investments
21,948,494
A$161.8m
0%
0.07%
3
4.56%
Franklin Resources, Inc.
15,821,920
A$116.6m
0%
0.03%
4
3.97%
Regal Funds Management Pty Limited
13,761,490
A$101.4m
0%
5.51%

This isfrom Wall Street journal analytic.
Institutions that own CHN

BlackRock Advisors (UK) Ltd.
2237770
0.65%
30248
0.01%
05/31/21
1
Franklin Advisers, Inc.
30102367
8.71%
0
100.00%
09/28/20
2
Invesco Advisers, Inc.
12931692
3.74%
12931692
0.02%
03/31/21
3
Quantex AG
829702
0.24%
829702
0.49%
04/30/21
4
Regal Funds Management Pty Ltd.
15411838
4.46%
-182131
98.31%
11/30/20

so, if others have more info, please share it hear,
at least we can find which dataset is more reliable,

	Thimothy Rupert Barr Goyder	37,198,724	10.8%
1	Franklin Advisers, Inc.	30,102,367	8.70%
2	Regal Funds Management Pty Ltd.	15,411,838	4.46%
3	Invesco Advisers, Inc.	12,931,692	3.74%
4	The Vanguard Group, Inc.	7,415,903	2.14%
5	Aegp Super Pty Ltd.	5,000,000	1.45%
6	Alexander Carl Dorsch	4,341,839	1.26%
7	Vanguard Investments Australia Ltd.	4,036,229	1.17%
8	BlackRock Fund Advisors	3,496,206	1.01%
9	Ilwella Pty Ltd.	2,365,000	0.68%

	Name	Number of Ordinary shares held	Percentage of capital held %
1	HSBC Custody Nominees	56,869,623	16.40
2	Citicorp Nominees Pty Limited	38,746,279	11.17
3	Mr Timothy R B Goyder	37,197,224	10.72
4	J P Morgan Nominees Australia Pty Limited	28,528,240	8.22
5	National Nominees Limited	8,570,443	2.47
6	CS Third Nominees Pty Limited	8,212,794	2.37
7	BNP Paribas Nominees Pty Ltd ACF Clearstream	6,486,077	1.87

1		10.72%	Timothy Rupert Goyder	37,198,724	A4.2m	0.01%	no data
2	6.33%	Goldman Sachs Group, Investment Banking and Securities Investments	21,948,494	A$161.8m	0%	0.07%
3	4.56%	Franklin Resources, Inc.	15,821,920	A$116.6m	0%	0.03%
4	3.97%	Regal Funds Management Pty Limited	13,761,490	A$101.4m	0%	5.51%

	BlackRock Advisors (UK) Ltd.	2237770	0.65%	30248	0.01%	05/31/21
1	Franklin Advisers, Inc.	30102367	8.71%	0	100.00%	09/28/20
2	Invesco Advisers, Inc.	12931692	3.74%	12931692	0.02%	03/31/21
3	Quantex AG	829702	0.24%	829702	0.49%	04/30/21
4	Regal Funds Management Pty Ltd.	15411838	4.46%	-182131	98.31%	11/30/20