I personally have never taken much notice of Malcy as I suspect...

I personally have never taken much notice of Malcy as I suspect he has a conflict of interest eg paid to promote or invests in these companies in his own name or otherwise and it is to his advantage to ramp/promote these companies, I believe he has a disclaimer that he doesnt own the stocks 'personally', but I dont own FAR personally either, my holdings are all held in trusts and also a company.

My question is does this bloke actually have a proven investment record over a number of years? As in does his entire list as a group consistently generate decent return?

If no one knows then I might plug his recent lists in a spreadsheet and compare their performance over the subsequent 12 months from the date the list was released.