CL1 0.00% $2.50 class limited

CL1 has been very disappointing - a long term holder - do I buy...

  1. 49 Posts.
    lightbulb Created with Sketch. 41
    CL1 has been very disappointing - a long term holder - do I buy more at this price as some of the substantial holders have been doing recently or do I cut my losses and move on to something else?

    I have attempted to model Class so I can compare and better analyse the FY21 results. More recently Class has not been very transparent on the revenue lines

    Happy to hear from other people who have modelled Class

    Class Super 176900 acc X ARPU of $223 = $39,448,700
    • 175630 accounts in Dec20
    • Have increased ARPU from $216 Dec20 to $223
    Class Portfolio 9700 acc X APRU of $130 = $1,261,000
    Class Engine $150,000
    Class Trust 6000 acc X ARPU of $200 = $1,200,000
    • Some big assumptions here and I think this is the segment that really needs to fire for Class to re-rate
    • June20 acc were 1683, Dec20 acc 2571, the product has really only just been launched and the revenue is still very small but potentially could grow as large as Class Super
    NowInfinity
    Fees $7,494,960
    • Based on the 4 months of disclosed trading in the June20 Accounts plus 10%
    • Could not find any info in Dec20 accounts
    Doc Sales $314,000
    • As for Fees
    Smartcorp $2,100,000
    • Based on the 4 months of trading shown in Dec20 accounts
    Reckon Docs $1,000,000
    • Based on presentation at time of acquisition
    Other revenue $22
    Model has revenue of $53,270,000 vs Company forecast revenue of $54,000,000

    Model EBITDA of $21,348,064 vs Company forecast of $21,600,000 both are based on Company forecast of 40% EBITDA margin

    The real complication with this is the amortisation of software R&D which has grown exponentially 1H19 - $4.4m, 2H19 - $4.6m, 1H20 - 5.5m, 2H20 - ????, 1H21 - $7.1m, forecast 2H21 - $11m) and is a total guess on my part.

    Depreciation $1,000,000 educated guess
    Amortisation $10,000,000 uneducated guess (Dec20 HY figure was $3,700,000)

    Using Company EBITDA forecast then NPBT $10,600,000

    30% tax rate

    NPAT $7,420,000 (Dec20 NPAT was $3,779,000)

    123,758,834 shares EPS 6.0cps

    CL1 is really a low EPS growth story and a PE ratio of 20 is pretty generous which leads to share price of $1.20 unless
    • Really ramp up Class Trust
    • Get some cross selling happening with the purchases
    • Get over the R&D hump - competition may prevent this from happening

    Market Screener - all of the above was not done checking below - but pretty close - interesting the 3 analysts following the stock have an average target price of $2.38
    https://hotcopper.com.au/data/attachments/3156/3156259-6dc9dd455337d49e1ceaf94c87e3f3bc.jpg
    https://hotcopper.com.au/data/attachments/3156/3156262-cf3c151b06eddf66401c7977d5caa6e7.jpg

    Shows the destruction in shareholder wealth over the last couple of years

    Cheers
 
watchlist Created with Sketch. Add CL1 (ASX) to my watchlist

Currently unlisted public company.

arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch. arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch.