Both true. I don't look at Adams any more they have been wrong...

Both true. I don't look at Adams any more they have been wrong on the optimistic side way too often. They seem to exist to sell excerpts to companies to make the companies case.

The future is bright for Lynas the question is when? All their projects are late so no chance for 2025. Look at price for NdPr 14 months ago. You can be certain that Revenue may be down 30~ 50 % and profits 50 ~ 75%. Remember when prices were going up, everyone said all prices increases went to the bottom line I do not agree with all, but the majority does. Why is that not true on the way down? I could use highs and lows to show how much Prices have dropped but I will use3 month averages and it is about 50% in 14 months

It totally amazes me that many of the holders claim they are in it for long haul then uses TA over just a few days or weeks to show why the stock is going to go up. If you are a long term holder does it not make more sense to use long term charts? Of course that does not make the point you want to make.

Using one day of LYS CF & DY makes even less sense. They are tracking stocks not independent stocks so they follow LYC not lead it! Now the average volume for LYC over last 10 days was 5.3M shares a day, 90 days 6.5m. For DY and CF, 10 day 1.6M about 30% .about 30% About 90 day was combined 0.232M 3.5% of LYC. So yes Volume is growing short term long term trend is below 5%. Also take a look at when volume was during recent rises or falls? How is what one day of LYS DY & CF give any indication to a long term holder? It does Not! It has signaled quite accurately what the next nights might be in AU. Why would a long term holder care?

Why do all the long-term holders on this board care about what the next day or week will do. They are long Tem holders should they not care what Next year will be? The only thing that tells that is long term guesses on Revenue and Profits. NdPr prices and shutdowns are key to that.
m. Those that claim to be long term holders seem to care about the next days or weeks and 2 ~4 years from now and totall ignore what will happen in the next 6 ~ 18 months.

Can any one on this board Explain why it makes sense to hold through a probable -25% change in stock price that current trends In NdPr prices say will happen. Because they think prices will climb in 18 to 36 months? Do not forget the book to bill delay which means we already know prices for Q4 and a good part, or all, of Q1.

Just my guess but most of those left on this board have Lynas as a substantial part of their portfolio, maybe 25% or more. They are grasping at straws so they do not need to realize what their' holding has done to their profits. Good old FOMO problem.

Your rebuttal to my chart says you are behaving more like day traders than Long term holders/