i am not playing short game. I will buy Lynas whan its future...

Who is the fool one who presents data or someone that can only say you are a fool with Zero back up? i am sure (from observing your behavior) this is a difficult question for you.

i am not playing short game. I will buy Lynas whan its future looks good. i have said many times I am not short please give me post # of why you think i am short!!!!

i am not looking for a quick buck i am looking for News and data that shows that Lynas will make a good profit in 6 to 12 months and hopefully a lot longer so i can hold for a long time. This window is sliding and I have had it for many years. Even when price was soaring The PE was over 50 and i would not buy.

Yes they are cutting production and i cannot disagree with you it is to save costs. They will save on Reagents and energy. Labor depends if they are willing to reduce work force. But what does that say. it says simply sya they cannot make money at these prices. i have no idea where REE prices are going but i doubt they will go up what they need in the near future.


Yes i too can find many examples of other markets and companies that have gone through the same thing in the past. Many have recovered nicely but it takes time. Could you please explain a couple of things.

1. How is it good investing to go through a fall that is 36% right now and has a high probability of being over 55% by next September. show what you see that will make prices go up in near future.
2. 2024 SAR will continue to be another disaster. Because of the book to bill delay we already know prices and AL has said they will cut back shipments at these prices. What do you see that will make prices go up between now and March 2025?

Here is a chart of past earnings and what 14 analysis (https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/LYC.AX/analysis) Note that the analysis think stock value will go down 73% this year which is worse than my prediction. Also the analysis did not change their predictions after Q3 CC I lowered mine and gave reasons. Lower prices and lower than expected production. Revenue for first 3 Qs was AUD 341M average was 113M. With what AL said in Q3 CC and prices continuing to fall. What do you think the chance of them having revenue of 764M for year is? I think my 445 will be much closer.

In future try to reply to what I said, not what you think I said (like shorting) If the only way you can show i am wrong is to fabricate what I say than I must be doing just fine.


Just noticed something Analysis have revenue dropping just a tinny bit. Fy 2023 to FY 2024 production and prices are both down their is no way they can be correct.
Production pay attention to 3 Q trailing average.



Prices visually calculate direction and magnitude of change. I do not think you need accuracy to see my point.