NEU (ASX) Neuren Media and Analyst Coverage

Originally posted by Steed1: ↑

Using Grok AI on the X Platform - following is an analysis of the estimated probability of success in the PMS Phase 3 trial - I included as much up to date information as possible including endpoints & number of participants.

Key Considerations:
Trofinetide’s Precedent (NNZ-2566):
Trofinetide’s FDA approval for Rett syndrome (March 2023, LAVENDER study, ~187 participants) validates the drug class and mechanism (e.g., neuroprotection, synaptic stabilization). NNZ-2591, as an analog, likely shares similar pharmacological properties, increasing confidence in its efficacy for PMS, which involves synaptic dysfunction due to SHANK3 mutations, akin to Rett syndrome.
Phase 2 Success in PMS, Angelman, and Pitt Hopkins:
NNZ-2591’s success in three Phase 2 trials across these syndromes demonstrates robust efficacy and safety. For PMS specifically, success on the VABS-3 Receptive-Raw Score and PMSA-C (previously CGI-I) in Phase 2 indicates effectiveness in addressing core deficits like communication and global symptom improvement. Phase 2 success typically correlates with a 70-80% Phase 3 success rate (BIO Industry Analysis, 2016-2020).
Improved Safety Profile:
NNZ-2591’s enhanced safety profile compared to trofinetide (which had manageable side effects like diarrhea and vomiting) reduces the risk of Phase 3 failure due to adverse events, critical in a 160-participant trial.
FDA-Mandated Phase 3 Endpoints:
The FDA’s requirement that Phase 3 endpoints match Phase 2—specifically, the VABS-3 Receptive-Raw Score and PMSA-C overall score—significantly de-risks the trial. These endpoints were met in Phase 2 for PMS, meaning NNZ-2591 has already demonstrated efficacy on these measures. The challenge is replicating results in a larger cohort.
VABS-3 Receptive-Raw Score: This measures receptive communication (e.g., understanding language), a core deficit in PMS. Its use in Phase 2 and sensitivity to treatment effects (as seen in trofinetide trials) supports reliability.
PMSA-C (previously CGI-I): This syndrome-specific global change measure assesses overall improvement in PMS symptoms (e.g., behavior, communication, motor function). Its prior use as CGI-I in Phase 2 and adaptation to PMSA-C suggests tailored sensitivity to PMS, enhancing trial robustness.
Phase 3 Trial Design for PMS:
Sample Size (160 participants, 1:1 randomization): With 80 participants per arm (drug vs. placebo), the trial is well-sized for a rare disease like PMS (1,000-2,000 cases worldwide). Trofinetide’s LAVENDER trial (187 participants) succeeded with similar sizing, suggesting adequate statistical power for detecting efficacy on VABS-3 and PMSA-C.
1:1 Placebo Control: Balanced randomization strengthens the trial’s ability to detect treatment effects, especially with validated, sensitive endpoints.
PMS-Specific Context:
PMS, caused by SHANK3 mutations, features intellectual disability, autism-like behaviors, and communication deficits. NNZ-2591’s Phase 2 success on VABS-3 Receptive-Raw Score and PMSA-C indicates it targets these deficits, likely via synaptic modulation, aligning with trofinetide’s mechanism.
Angelman and Pitt Hopkins Trials to Follow:
The current focus is the PMS Phase 3 trial. Phase 2 success in Angelman and Pitt Hopkins supports NNZ-2591’s broader potential but does not directly impact the PMS trial estimate.
Remaining Risks:
Scale-Up Challenges: The 160-participant trial may reveal rare adverse events or efficacy variations due to patient heterogeneity. The improved safety profile mitigates this, but PMS’s variable phenotype (e.g., differing communication deficits) could affect outcomes.
Recruitment for Rare Disease: PMS’s low prevalence may challenge recruitment, but 160 participants is feasible with multi-site or global enrollment, as seen in trofinetide’s trials.
Endpoint Sensitivity: While VABS-3 and PMSA-C are validated, their sensitivity in a larger cohort could vary if patient baselines differ significantly. However, Phase 2 success on these exact measures reduces this risk.
Trial Execution: Success hinges on consistent endpoint measurement, patient retention, and protocol adherence. The FDA’s endpoint alignment minimizes design risks.
Refined Success Rate Estimate:
The baseline Phase 3 success rate for neurological drugs is ~40-50%, lower for rare neurodevelopmental disorders due to complex endpoints and small patient populations. NNZ-2591’s advantages are compelling:
Trofinetide’s approval validates the drug class and mechanism.
Phase 2 success in PMS on VABS-3 Receptive-Raw Score and PMSA-C demonstrates efficacy on the exact Phase 3 endpoints.
Improved safety profile reduces adverse event risks.
FDA-mandated endpoint alignment ensures Phase 3 measures outcomes NNZ-2591 already achieved.
Trial size (160 participants) is appropriate, with 1:1 randomization supporting robust statistical power.
Industry data (Nature Reviews Drug Discovery, 2018) suggests drugs with Phase 2 success on identical FDA-approved endpoints can achieve 80-90% Phase 3 success rates in favorable cases. For NNZ-2591 in PMS, the specific endpoint match (VABS-3 Receptive-Raw Score, PMSA-C) and prior success in these measures elevate confidence. I estimate a 82-92% Phase 3 success probability. The high end (92%) reflects the de-risking from endpoint alignment, Phase 2 data, and improved safety, while the lower end (82%) accounts for potential patient variability or recruitment challenges in a rare disease trial.
Additional Notes:
The VABS-3 Receptive-Raw Score is well-established in neurodevelopmental trials (e.g., used in Rett syndrome studies), and its raw score focus ensures sensitivity to small changes in PMS patients, who often have severe communication deficits.
The PMSA-C, evolving from CGI-I, is likely tailored to PMS-specific symptoms, enhancing its relevance. Its Phase 2 success suggests it captures meaningful clinical improvements.
The 160-participant size aligns with successful rare disease trials (e.g., trofinetide’s LAVENDER study), and 1:1 randomization supports detecting moderate effect sizes seen in Phase 2.

Expand

This is great stuff. I took a slightly different approach - looking at the research on why Phase 3s/FDA approval fails despite a successful Phase 2. Will post some of this at some point (I used old fashioned human research, which may or may not be better).

I'd love to see what you get if you put the same prompts in the best version of ChatGPT, and the paid version of Gemini.

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	266	$13.10

No.

Vol.

Price($)

266

$13.10

Price($)	Vol.	No.
$13.15	1619	2

Price($)

Vol.

No.

$13.15

1619

No.	Vol.	Price($)
1	667	13.080
2	154	13.000
1	77	12.930
1	39	12.920
1	21	12.900

No.

Vol.

Price($)

667

13.080

154

13.000

12.930

12.920

12.900

Price($)	Vol.	No.
13.190	1305	1
13.560	2250	1
13.880	748	1
14.000	60	1
14.020	10000	1

Price($)

Vol.

No.

13.190

1305

13.560

2250

13.880

748

14.000

14.020

10000

(20min delay)
Last $13.10		Change -0.800(5.76%)		Mkt cap ! $1.629B

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
$13.95	$13.96	$12.88	$9.534M	725.6K

This is great stuff. I took a slightly different approach -...

ASX Ltd notches upward on sale of company meant to fix CHESS 3 years ago

Week 24 Wrap: WW3 looms (again); US econ data tepid & silver surfing

Zip's stunning comeback: Is this the start of a $14 revival?

Iberian expansion: Megado turns to Europe with Spanish copper mines

Resolution's dual-listing to 'expedite growth' – and sets stage for NASDAQ foray

'Sure to be busy': Advance's Yuquivo drilling gets off to top start with first-hole hits

HotCopper Highlights, Week 24: Israel boosts Energy; Meeka eyes production & Mag7 back

Gold, Brent Crude spike as Israel strikes Iran in worst-case scenario

Clinuvel shares dip, even as CEO comes back from temp leave

Listen: HotCopper Wire Podcast 013 - They changed the IPO rules (and that's a good thing)

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News

This is great stuff. I took a slightly different approach -...

Top Stories

ASX Ltd notches upward on sale of company meant to fix CHESS 3 years ago

Week 24 Wrap: WW3 looms (again); US econ data tepid & silver surfing

Zip's stunning comeback: Is this the start of a $14 revival?

Iberian expansion: Megado turns to Europe with Spanish copper mines

Resolution's dual-listing to 'expedite growth' – and sets stage for NASDAQ foray

'Sure to be busy': Advance's Yuquivo drilling gets off to top start with first-hole hits

HotCopper Highlights, Week 24: Israel boosts Energy; Meeka eyes production & Mag7 back

Gold, Brent Crude spike as Israel strikes Iran in worst-case scenario

Clinuvel shares dip, even as CEO comes back from temp leave

Listen: HotCopper Wire Podcast 013 - They changed the IPO rules (and that's a good thing)

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News