JMO You will not answer because you are clueless on how to...

JMO You will not answer because you are clueless on how to predict it and know any price that supports your Buy sentiment will turn out to be very wrong. This is scarry for you and that is why you can only post insults and not discuss opinions.

Fist as you said it is a prediction. Prediction can be wrong. If you think Prediction are "Moronic" why dont you have a sentiment of none as apposed to "Buy" your inconsistency is obvious.

Yes everything I post is published and available to every body Q, SAR, and AR are very important documents do you even read and comprehend them? The fact is a high % of traders including pros do little research they listen to friends. That is why stocks are so volatile. for example the 14 Analysis that Yahoo uses were predicting 5 months ago that Lynas would make AUD 0.20 EPS. Now they are down to 0.10 which is still high. I am sure all theses analysis had the same information as me. also i moved my estimate down when AL said they would inventory some production in Q3 CC Not one of them change there estimates till 2 months latter. l see the real revenue # in two weeks I suppose you find predicting this "Moronic" to even have a guess what it will be.

You asked where I have been correct, and I forgot an important one. One that if you had thought about may have caused you to sell in the AUD 8~10 range. 18 months ago.

1. My prediction for NdPrO prices in 2022, 700~ 800 RMB WV Though it did go out of this range once on the high side for a year it was in range or below.
2. My prediction June 2023 was 450 ~ 550 RMB At I added lines showing it on my detailed chart i publish different charts Never went over was below most of the time.
3. My latest prediction in June 2024 is 400 ` 500 RMB This is the one I base my revenue estimates on. Again it is below. I believe by June 2025 it will be in the range. Yes, I think prices will go up. It is not nearly high enough to support a SP of 6.00 at a PE of 30.

.
In spite of being high on all of these you and many other label me as a down ramper. The only thing that makes me a down ramper is that my predictions are so much lower than yours's and others dreams which have nothing to support them.

Here is my current price chart with RMB axis expanded so you can see the high range. Think about it and you just might sell. Of course for you to be concerned you would have to have some idea of what prices Lynas needs to support a SP of 6.00 at a PE of 30 and I suspect you are clueless on that. All it would take is a little understanding of SARs and ARs and simple math to know answer. You would have to read and understand the note sections. The notes especially in AR have a wealth of information that really helps to understand the past and make accurate predictions about future.