Look guys, instead of arguing about who is right or wrong, why...

Look guys, instead of arguing about who is right or wrong, why don't you just find out.

Rules of the game
1. Both parties must disclose all trades relating to GGY on hotcopper ie date purchased, quantity and price.
2. Honesty is of course the best policy
3. Profits or losses will be calculated separately for each individual when all GGY holdings have been sold.
4. Prize for the winner will be bragging rights.
5. Judges decision is final.

So are you guys confident enough of your own trading styles to disclose your trades.

If you want, I will keep track of your trades and post and update on who's making more money at regular intervals.

This will determine once and for all whether it's better to trade GGY (rkjk) ie. trying to pick the highs and lows or to simply hold GGY long term (Nobby) ie. buy and hold through ups and downs.

kellymm, you're welcome to join in as well if you're game