The information contained is relevant to this thread because it deals with the PEER COMPARISONS discussion, the calls for supporting information and the links to such information for research purposes. It also tries to shed light on the reasons why things might be as they are between peers.
This Study material is not a cross promotion, this Study lays out the official data in comparable form for research purposes by investors, links to data are included.
For the purposes of supplementary documentation, I have used a number of additional sources that will highlight certain aspects of certain claims. I will also provide explanations in my conclusions.
While I am doing this comparison, It should be noted that my intention is to show a side by side comparison without emotional bias.
I have no regard for emotion or point scoring in this body of work, to support this I am supplying all links to support my understanding, my time is precious to me and I do not intend dealing with anything that is not officially documented through the ASX or Independent Research Facilities.
I place a lower emphasis on company presentations because they rarely contain more than headlines.
The following side by side comparative table is easily read and compared dealing with STUDY facts.
You will note that there are 2 parts to the presented TABLE
The first section surrounded by the black margin is information from the STUDIES.
The second section not surrounded by the black margin is sourced information from other ASX or Official Resource Documents.
RED
AUZ and ARL Feasibility Study Comparison Ardea Resources Australian Mines Initial Mine Life 25 YEARS 18 YEARS Total Resource is much larger, +50 years AUZ, back to drilling (increase resources) Autoclave Throughput 2.25 Mtpa 2.0 Mtpa PREProduction Capital Estimate US $918 Million (Sulphate) US $974 Million (Sulphate) Costing above for Nickel Sulfate Costing above for Nickel Sulfate There is a pivot to MHP underway There is a pivot to MHP underway No DFS STUDY on costs for MHP capex No BFS STUDY on costs for MHP capex Realistic for similar MHP capex (comparable size) Implied MHP capex $US$832 Million Payback In Years 5.1 Years 5.2 Years Longer payback IRR Internal Rate Of Return (Post Tax) 27% 15% Higher percentage returns Lower Percentage returns Average C1 Operational Costs ( Inclusive of Credits) (US $0.34) /LB NICKEL US $0.48 / LB NICKEL Nickel / Cobalt Nickel / Cobalt / Scandium Over Recovery due to cutoff grades This $ recovery includes Scandium Average C1 Operational Costs ( NICKEL Only) US $4.63 /LB NICKEL US $5.73 / LB NICKEL Nickel Only Nickel Only Higher cutoff grades result in lower cost/ ton Sconi/ lower cutoff grade higher cost More ore needs processing Additional C1 Operational Credits (Not accounted for YET) Sufficient Onsite Neutralizer NO Onsite neutralizer Autoclave Ore Neutralizer is an onsite resource Autoclave Ore Neutralizer is a buy in cost Scandium exists NOT accounted for YET Scandium Fully accounted for in C1 Rare Earths exist NOT accounted For YET No Rare Earths Nickel Feed Grade 0.81% Nickel 0.67% Nickel Higher Grade Lower Grade Higer C1 operational cost recovery Lower C1 operational cost recovery Cobalt Feed Grade 0.1% Cobalt 0.1% Cobalt Capability to Increase Plant Tonnage Expansion 100 year SUPPLY, Larger Resource @2.25mtpa 30 Year FINITE CAPACITY of known resource Nickel MHP Nickel MHP Goongarrie is a small part of KNP (known) AUZ is going back to drilling YES Resource allows increased production P/A NO total capacity 30 years @ 2Mtpa Add extra autoclaves + leach circuit, YES Resource capacity @2mtpa / 30 years NO Potential supply, 100 years Increase Resources (Announcement) ??? Capability to use 1 new plant for entire company resource YES NO Goongarrie and KNP are all one resource WA Sconi and Flemington are 1900km apart One Production Hub 2 Individual plant builds required, Extra cost Rail Infrastructure (Working) YES NO A working rail line is onsite in Goongarrie This has been dismantled, no rails. NO Rail Infrastructure for Battery Metals Export) YES NO Direct Working Rail to Esperance Port NO Working Rail to Kwinana Battery Hub NO Road Infrastructure YES YES Availability of NICKEL SULFIDE onsite YES NO Nickel Sulfide to increase grade output to 1% NO Nickel Sulfide to compliment OUTPUT grade NO Globally Significant Resource (Recognised) YES NO Largest Nickel Resource in WA & OZ NO 7th largest in the world NO Resource Comparison (Nickel Tonne) 5,458,400 Tonnes 735,933 Tonnes Ardea Nickel Resource is 7.41 times larger AUZ Nickel Resource is 7.41 times Smaller Reserve Comparison (Nickel Tonne) 329,458 331,357 Cutoff Grade @ 0.82% Cutoff Grade @ 0.58% Similar Reserve in tonnage Similar Reserve in tonnage Higher Cut Off Grade % LowerCut Off Grade % Higer Grade % needs less processing / tonne Lower Grade % needs more processing / tonne Lower C1 costs per Tonne Nickel Higher C1 costs per Tonne Nickel GOLD Resources on leases / tenements YES NO 11,800 (OZ) Gold NO Big Four Resource 100% owned NWM was sold Mining Infrastructure and Industrial Facility WA Kalgoorlie is the mining capital of OZ QLD Greenvale is NOT a mining capital Surrounding infrastructure is mining intensive Surrounding infrastructure is farm and military Kalgoorlie population 29,032 People Greenvale Population 232 People Intensive mining activity Very little mining activity Working rail running through the mining lease NO rail at allto GreenvaleRemoved Quality of Management (Subjective Qualities) Clean Track Record ASIC Investigation Underway Share Consolidation 10/1 Repeated Capital Raises Management Available and tested Management Contact AvailIblity (None ) None noted Repeated Administrative corrections Trustworthy I have NO Trust in management Effective money managers, prudent attitude. Not effective money managers Consistent focus on core goals and assets Self Interest is Shareholder consensus 4 x Capital Raisings since 2017 10 x capital raisings since 2017 Share Related Matters Shares on issue 169,737,772 Shares on issue 462,531,610 Share Price $1.02 Share Price $0.088 Market Capitalisation $173,132,527.00 Market Capitalization $40,702,787.00 Capital Raising Events 08-02-17 $1,000,000.00 05-04-17 $2,000,000.00 15-09-17 $5,540,000.00 06-11-17 $20,000,000.00 11-09-18 $12,000,000.00 27-02-19 $5,000,000.00 17-07-19 $5,800,000.00 09-10-20 $4,800,000.00 14-04-20 $14,500,000.00 26-07-20 $5,200,000.00 28-06-21 $5,700,000.00 28-07-21 $6,500,000.00 22-02-22 $21,500,000.00 30-05-22 $3,700,000.00 17-06-2022 TBA $3,700,000.00 Total Raised $37,540,000.00 Total Raised $79,400,000.00 Market Capitalisation $150,217,928.00 Market Capitalization $38,852,655.00 Valuation/ value created $ $112,677,928.00 Valuation/ Value Created $ -$40,547,345.00 Valuation/ value created % 300.15% Valuation/ Value Created % -51.07% Date 19/06/2022 Date 19/06/2022 NOTE NOTE ARL M/C is worth substantially MORE than AUZ's M/Cap is worth $38,7 Million less than the the capital raised, therefore it stands to reason Total capital raised since 2017 to date that management are more effective That is a very sobering thought MY CLOSING THOUGHTS RICH DAD POOR DAD The Author Robert Kyosaki wrote the decades old investment book called Rich Dad - Poor Dad The basis of the story revolved around Gratification NOW or Gratification LATER Highly recommended reading
- Forums
- ASX - By Stock
- PEER Comparisons
The information contained is relevant to this thread because it...
-
- There are more pages in this discussion • 149 more messages in this thread...
You’re viewing a single post only. To view the entire thread just sign in or Join Now (FREE)
Featured News
Add ARL (ASX) to my watchlist
(20min delay)
|
|||||
Last
41.0¢ |
Change
0.010(2.50%) |
Mkt cap ! $81.86M |
Open | High | Low | Value | Volume |
40.0¢ | 41.0¢ | 40.0¢ | $1.304K | 3.194K |
Buyers (Bids)
No. | Vol. | Price($) |
---|---|---|
5 | 253196 | 39.5¢ |
Sellers (Offers)
Price($) | Vol. | No. |
---|---|---|
42.0¢ | 27496 | 1 |
View Market Depth
No. | Vol. | Price($) |
---|---|---|
5 | 253196 | 0.395 |
1 | 3589 | 0.390 |
1 | 48085 | 0.385 |
1 | 1500 | 0.380 |
2 | 15686 | 0.375 |
Price($) | Vol. | No. |
---|---|---|
0.420 | 27496 | 1 |
0.430 | 24407 | 1 |
0.440 | 16590 | 1 |
0.450 | 20000 | 1 |
0.470 | 660 | 1 |
Last trade - 12.05pm 13/11/2024 (20 minute delay) ? |
Featured News
ARL (ASX) Chart |
The Watchlist
NUZ
NEURIZON THERAPEUTICS LIMITED
Michael Thurn, CEO & MD
Michael Thurn
CEO & MD
SPONSORED BY The Market Online