In terms of player performance you would have him stay but for the sake of the team, culture and pies harmony, you would probably get him to go.
So much risk in having him stay? he could be part of a team winning a flag but he could cause a lack of flags for a few years before a team rebuild.
Reminds me of that fictional Collingwood player, Geoff Hayward, in Williamson’s The Club? The Club was fictional, De Goey at Collingwood May not have a playwright’s ending?
