yeah im not looking for tricks. but as you say it is of variable...

yeah im not looking for tricks. but as you say it is of variable quality.... that was his main point and its is valid. does it disprove anything? no but there is uncertainty and those error bars are absent from the discussion in most forums, so to be fair to the guy the adjectives used here are unwarranted. I hazard a guess that that guy is more intelligent on a bad day than your average poster on their best!