No problem with contrary views but just negative comments...

No problem with contrary views but just negative comments without substance versus negative view back up by facts much more appreciated.

Key risk for me at the moment is recoveries from CIL and the shale issue and in particular a) how significant an issue it is ie how widespread through the tailings which has not yet been confirmed and b) additional costs of addressing the shale issue

a) and b) are not mutually independant...but that is the answers needed and positive answers on both for the share price to rocket north....until we have clear answers on a) and b) above that is key risk for me with this stock at the moment..