There has been some debate on this thread as towhether the...

  1. 22,730 Posts.
    lightbulb Created with Sketch. 769
    There has been some debate on this thread as to
    whether the Maidan gig was a revolution or a revolutionary Coup.

    I tend to favour the latter so far because:

    There are 2 elements to a revolution: intentions and outcomes

    While the intention of the Maidan mob was to
    (a) distance the Ukraine from Russia
    (b) join the EC & NATOand as such align itself with the west

    The outcome (so far) has been different in that (b) since 2014 the Ukraine has
    lost the Crimea and a fair chunk of SE Ukraine (18% in total) it is arguable
    that the Ukraine Maidan has not achieved its objectives as per (a) & (b) above)
    so , in summary the Maidan (so far) has to be classified as a revolutionary coup d'etat

    https://hotcopper.com.au/data/attachments/6180/6180547-05926a41f7c4f7ac3d0efdbec95c2685.jpg
    (source : commonweb.unifr.ch)

    The bottom line is that if the Ukraine manages to join the EC & NATO and completely divorce itself from Russia ,
    then it can be said that 2013-14 was a revolution. But of course the jury is still out and its a matter of opinion
    until the fat lady sings....is it a revolution or a revolutionary coup d'état ?

 
arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch. arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch.