Segal vs Robertson, page-74

  1. 10,465 Posts.
    lightbulb Created with Sketch. 88
    I want to learn to how to criticise Israel without being accused in most cases by pro Israeli poster’s claiming many of my post as discriminatory etc

    1 Israel current actions against Gaza amounts to genocide….probably deemed as antisemitic.

    2 Israel action by the IDF in Gaza amounts to genocidal act not to dissimilar to Turkish troops against the Armenian community in the 20 century.…...I believe this construct would not be considered as being antisemitic under the IHRA guidelines.

    Simply wanted clarification on how to go about constructing a criticism on Israel without it being considered as antisemitic

    I asked poster’s to come up with examples so that I can get a better understanding of the intention of the IHRA guidelines.
    It appears that it is too difficult for 822 or Par to draft any examples.

    As far as I can decipher the intent of the IHRA guidelines including M Dreyfus comments is that my No. 2 fits the bill.

    If my assessment isn’t correct…then any negative comments about Israel or Jews are antisemitic!

 
arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch. arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch.