i would have to agree with most of what your saying. IMO this thread had become a tipping/ramping thread. were i think it would be more beneficial to go over the whys,hows and whens.
i also think keeping a track of the winner/losers is mistake as it becomes more a competition rather than education.
i hate giving tips and would rather help people find there own stocks (teach a man to fish bla bla)i am in no means saying i know every thing but i think i can point people in the right direction or at least ask a question.
i also feel if we get quality posts on how systems work it gives everybody a chance to try new things in there system that may improve there returns
