HIO (ASX) Strategic Delusion. In-situ grade not scale the first priority. Catch 22?

Originally posted by Pyroxene: ↑

Fourteen years after discovery and the immutable economic impediment of the Hawsons' Project very low in-situ "ore" grade has finally been admitted by the current board.

Approximately $40m in the last 18 months has been wasted pursuing a palpably flawed technical approach of maximizing resource tonnage at the expense of the in-situ "ore" and product grade. Do not be tricked, it’s this flawed technical strategy, as much as any claims of an unfavorable economic environment that scuttled a successful outcome for the scheduled Dec 2022 BFS. The complete lack of any senior geological resource and operational iron ore mining experience on the board nakedly evident.

The dubious strategic review findings as outlined are an obituary. Further investment in the scandalously slow paced and likely to fail 18 month BFS timetable is reckless folly. It’s difficult not to be cynical that the only credible raising purpose is employee salary preservation.

For too long HIO, and before that CAP, management have obfuscated and deluded themselves about the false primacy of scale and the final product grade – “supergrade” iron ore was always a marketing delusion.

The revised production of 11 Mtpa of magnetite concentrate is the same as that proposed a decade ago. Why has the project burned so much more capital to land where it started?

The proposed 20 Mtpa production was always delusional. Per the latest in-situ resource grade and stripping ratio information, roughly 230 Mtpa of rock has to be mined and processed to achieve this. This would be an operation moving more than twice the volume of rock as Australia’s largest current IO mine at BHP-Yandi - hardly credible. The halved strategic review target of 11 Mtpa would still rival or exceed the largest Pilbara pits. Also an incredible but not completely impossible objective.

The Strategic Review's proposed 400km slurry pipeline and the Myponie Point export port are non-existent and illogical fantasy. Both require huge capital, reams of approvals and many years if not a decade to complete. Objectives that are utterly counter to the stated critical high capex problem.

The board is engaging in Catch 22 “logic”. The capital/operational costs of the project are too high because the in-situ grade is low and, the capital/operational costs must be high because the grade is low so the only path to viability is huge scale…..

So no hope you say? Probably but it’s still possible Catch 22 could be dodged with some expert management.

There is a tried and tested, real world plan, not properly explored in the strategic review findings that could be quickly and cheaply assessed.

It would go something like this:

i) establish if (?) a discrete >20% DTR grade “starter core” resource as close to surface as possible (will be deeper than ~100m oxidation base) is present at Hawsons. It should be very quick and cheap to assess as in excess of $40m has been spent just oon drilling in last fourteen years - lots of detailed data is available.

ii) if, and only if, a “starter core” exists then redesign all engineering and costs based on producing a modest 2-5 Mtpa of concentrate using existing road, rail and port infrastructure to get a mine started and prove viability – a much ,much lower capital outlay and risk approach, and,

iii) Once proved viable via an initial operation then co-operate with (or acquire) other SA Braemar projects to incrementally develop and de-risk major capital infrastructure to scale-up and unlock the potential value of the giant low grade resources tonnages.

The odds are still very slim but a “start small” method utilizing existing infrastructure (an astonishingly ignored project advantage) is far more realistic and it minimizes wealth destruction risks.

Bottom line-- if there’s no higher grade “starter core” of roughly 20% DTR grade then Hawsons is uneconomic and should be stowed. Catch 22 wins.

If there is a “starter core” resource then define it fast (no more than 3-6 months) and finish a BFS in 9 months, not 18. The Braemar Province is unproved, it can only progress with modest and credible capital outlay development proposals.

Once some real operational credibility has bee established then others with deep pockets and the government will take note.

As it stands, the Strategic Review and revised BFS program is just another script in over a decade of hackneyed Tolkienesque productions.

Expand

understand your intentions to downramp SP to buy cheap shares.. wonder how much time and energy you have to post on stock you don't hold ...

btw, please read the management team on hawsons website there are few people with geology background.

even Quentin hill was a geologist when PFS was completed..

No.	Vol.	Price($)
30	8435624	1.7¢

No.

Vol.

Price($)

8435624

1.7¢

Price($)	Vol.	No.
1.8¢	2266598	3

Price($)

Vol.

No.

1.8¢

2266598

No.	Vol.	Price($)
29	8185624	0.017
31	4953143	0.016
16	3639721	0.015
8	4045999	0.014
4	659633	0.013

No.

Vol.

Price($)

8185624

0.017

4953143

0.016

3639721

0.015

4045999

0.014

659633

0.013

Price($)	Vol.	No.
0.018	2266598	3
0.019	1302825	5
0.020	2180000	3
0.021	1307833	3
0.022	1307678	7

Price($)

Vol.

No.

0.018

2266598

0.019

1302825

0.020

2180000

0.021

1307833

0.022

1307678

(20min delay)
Last 1.8¢		Change 0.000(0.00%)		Mkt cap ! $20.31M

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
1.8¢	1.8¢	1.8¢	$41.76K	2.322M

Strategic Delusion. In-situ grade not scale the first priority. Catch 22?, page-3

Astute delivers high-grade lithium hits at Red Mountain

Renascor produces graphite concentrate at Siviour, right on time to meet ex-China demand

Listen: HotCopper Wire Podcast 019 – Dreaming of the 9,000s

Most investors will get this earnings season wrong. Will you?

Firetail scoops up untested land around Excelsior – including juicy mineralisation target

Rokeby, BHM, more: The 10 hot stocks HotCopper users watchlisted in Week 30

ASX Market Close: Fading miners drag bourse as iron ore price slumps | July 25

What is going on here? Watch out for DroneShield, Pure Hydrogen, and Nel ASA

St George banks $5M from placement to ramp up Araxá Rare Earths Project

Friday's HotCopper trends: Renascor concentrate, Larvotto raise | July 25

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News

Strategic Delusion. In-situ grade not scale the first priority. Catch 22?, page-3

Top Stories

Astute delivers high-grade lithium hits at Red Mountain

Renascor produces graphite concentrate at Siviour, right on time to meet ex-China demand

Listen: HotCopper Wire Podcast 019 – Dreaming of the 9,000s

Most investors will get this earnings season wrong. Will you?

Firetail scoops up untested land around Excelsior – including juicy mineralisation target

Rokeby, BHM, more: The 10 hot stocks HotCopper users watchlisted in Week 30

ASX Market Close: Fading miners drag bourse as iron ore price slumps | July 25

What is going on here? Watch out for DroneShield, Pure Hydrogen, and Nel ASA

St George banks $5M from placement to ramp up Araxá Rare Earths Project

Friday's HotCopper trends: Renascor concentrate, Larvotto raise | July 25

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News