1 - Well, rising costs while commodity price is falling. So, you...

1 - Well, rising costs while commodity price is falling. So, you say extraordinary cashflow on weaker price. Not happening right now or from here on with coming debt to compact the situation. I won't elaborate on the parts you do not understand because anyone who has read recent reports would see margins are thin, dividend small and all things pointing at mediocrity.

2 - Thats pretty obvious nowadays. If you actually read and place any value on analysts' reports, you are already far from a contrarian, but rather a member of the flock. To think that the big players that move the price are relying on analysts' reports to drive their decisions is the most gullible mindset I can imagine. Who do you think pays the wages of the analysts? Why would they exclude that until now?

3 - I may.

4 - Thats all past information. Politics can switch from left leaning to right faster than you can say bingo. The pricing of coal companies does not indicate any level of abandonment of this industry. It's our no2 export. If what you say was actually true, all coal sites would be mothballed and mines would be used to grow dandelions for the hippies to frolics within. Right wing ideology is far more prevalent now.