He/She adds value by pointing out the risks for people to...

"Why are you here non holder?" Its not a forum for holders only Pal, despite that being ideal for some people with an overly optimistic outlook who never discuss the risk of the project.

"I assume you are a failed investor who wants to warn others that investing in mining stocks is risky and because you don't have the nerve to invest nobody else should take the risk either because there is no guarantee of success." Blatant straw man argument.

"anyone who invest" A generalization you've concocted to support your overall prejudice. People of all backgrounds view these forums (holders and non holders) and the more information they have, the better off they are making decisions - Risk, then Opportunity.

East Coast gets paid (by the company) to promote the company don't they? Would we expect them to provide anything other that a glowing reference? Their caveat is "if the get financing" - so the question is, what has changed from the point they were denied finance and now? There maybe something, buts it not clear to the market and until it is, then nothing has changed and risks need to be considered.

He/She adds value by pointing out the risks for people to consider or not. If you don't, then sweet, otherwise its not your role to limit his HC rights.