Australia's largest stock trading and investment forum Australia's #1 stock forum

The Misunderstanding, page-447

First 447 Last

Share
Profile

Follow
arnison

40 Posts.

29/06/25

11:41

Post #: 79611309
Share

Ibn Ashaq is not recognised by Muslims as an accurate historian. Keep trying.

Originally posted by DBT9: ↑

Not true.

Muhammad’s Raids on the Caravans
Ibn Ishaq records that Muhammad, after having settled in Medina, would either lead or send his Companions out on raids with the intention of enriching both himself and his followers from the plunder that would be gained from these expeditions. Ibn Ishaq wrote:
The apostle had not been given permission to fight or allowed to shed blood BEFORE THE SECOND ‘AQABA. He had simply been ordered to call men to God and to endure insult and forgive the ignorant. The Quraysh had persecuted his followers, seducing some from their religion, and exiling others from their country. They had to choose whether to give up their religion, be maltreated at home, or to flee the country, some to Abyssinia, others to Medina.

Muhammad’s claim that he hadn’t commanded them to attack the caravan in the sacred month is nothing more than a lame excuse since he was the one who had sent them out at a time in which he knew the sacred month was close at hand. It is little wonder that this caused the Meccans to be angry to the point that they were now forced to go to war with Muhammad and his companions to save honor.
In other words, Muhammad again is the one who instigated the fight between the Meccans and himself by doing something considered shameful and despicable in the eyes of even some of his own companions.

https://www.answering-islam.org/Shamoun/antagonizing.htm

Expand
Upvote

Reply

Top Stories

Week 26 Wrap: Renewable gas fantasies; RBA July cut hope builds; copper's August peak?

PAR

Paradigm Biopharmaceuticals makes key acquisition moving into FY26

Listen: HotCopper Wire Podcast 015 – Yeah, we're thinking the IPO market is back

OCC

Orthocell sees 4% jump as Remplir used in first US surgery. But is that low?

HotCopper Highlights Week 26: Droneshield 2.0; Trigg re-jig & Virgin

SRL

Sunrise pops on top scandium hits NSW explorer will now use for 'multi-decade' plan

RMX

Red Mountain: Chip samples point to 'large orogenic antimony mineral system' at Oaky Creek

AII

NATO’s 5% target: Why Almonty Industries’ mega mine and NASDAQ listing are a perfect fit for investors

MVF

Monash IVF shares cater 25% – Disaster or deep-value play?

BPH

Australia’s gas crisis is here – and dying coal plants aren’t helping

First 447 Last

The Misunderstanding, page-447

Week 26 Wrap: Renewable gas fantasies; RBA July cut hope builds; copper's August peak?

Paradigm Biopharmaceuticals makes key acquisition moving into FY26

Listen: HotCopper Wire Podcast 015 – Yeah, we're thinking the IPO market is back

Orthocell sees 4% jump as Remplir used in first US surgery. But is that low?

HotCopper Highlights Week 26: Droneshield 2.0; Trigg re-jig & Virgin

Sunrise pops on top scandium hits NSW explorer will now use for 'multi-decade' plan

Red Mountain: Chip samples point to 'large orogenic antimony mineral system' at Oaky Creek

NATO’s 5% target: Why Almonty Industries’ mega mine and NASDAQ listing are a perfect fit for investors

Monash IVF shares cater 25% – Disaster or deep-value play?

Australia’s gas crisis is here – and dying coal plants aren’t helping

Featured News

Featured News

The Misunderstanding, page-447

Top Stories

Week 26 Wrap: Renewable gas fantasies; RBA July cut hope builds; copper's August peak?

Paradigm Biopharmaceuticals makes key acquisition moving into FY26

Listen: HotCopper Wire Podcast 015 – Yeah, we're thinking the IPO market is back

Orthocell sees 4% jump as Remplir used in first US surgery. But is that low?

HotCopper Highlights Week 26: Droneshield 2.0; Trigg re-jig & Virgin

Sunrise pops on top scandium hits NSW explorer will now use for 'multi-decade' plan

Red Mountain: Chip samples point to 'large orogenic antimony mineral system' at Oaky Creek

NATO’s 5% target: Why Almonty Industries’ mega mine and NASDAQ listing are a perfect fit for investors

Monash IVF shares cater 25% – Disaster or deep-value play?

Australia’s gas crisis is here – and dying coal plants aren’t helping

Featured News

Featured News