I never claimed you shorted the stock, ever! I am claiming negativity was high on this stock back a few years ago with many members and now the truth comes out that at least one of them was shorting and making profit! Hence if I had seen this holders disclosure as HELD (Shorting) then it would make sense!
You have been extremely critical of the the stock (CSX) the entire time, at least your constant! and me of course, and that's your choice!