Can either of you justify your oversold comments using the most...

If it was just a short term shut down I would have no concerns at all. But the stock has been falling for a year driven by low REE prices and the failure of Lynas to complete Start or complete any project on time and reach the original name plate expectations. This is why I say sell the stock and buy back when there is clear indications Lynas will start doing what they say

There was no shut down in Q1 but look at these two charts and explain why anyone should be buying like you said. they can barely make original name plate never mind NEXT production rates.




here is revenue is this a company you want to invest in knowing revenue will go down and no clear indication what will make it go up after the shutdown



10yeas ago you held through a 95% fall in stock price without ever evaluating what you did wrong the stock is now at 25% of what it was back then. I fully believe you bought a boat load at the bottom. which was a great move. You look at this company as a first-born child and that is part of the reason you failed to see the problems at KAL when you visited about a year ago. It is time for you to start looking at this as an investor rather than a parent.

Can either of you justify your oversold comments using the most common Market metrics? In case you do not know they are Profits, Revenue, Book Value Per share. Profit and Revenue have both fallen more than SP and will continue to do so for SAR and AR. Which says tthe stock has to fll a lot to catch up. Book Value is going up but very slowly and is unlikely to support even a 4.00 SP after SAR and AR. All the Up rampers love to say oversold but I have not read one word justifying this position.. Just because a certain majority on this forum says it does not make it true.

If you do not like the standard metrics then tell us all what you are using and why you think it is oversold. The stock price a year or more in past is not a very good justification.