Oh really. Here we have another saga. Madamswer loves to refer...

Oh really.

Here we have another saga.

Madamswer loves to refer to the past, how about the fact that for the first six months or so of his posts ignored the upside, and the science, almost entirely. He kept comparing MSB to established blue chips and even refused to go to the MSB website. This continued until very recently.

Some analysis!

These days you still give no serious consideration to the upside and with it, the science. There is simply no proper context for his constant claims.

Could it be that a manipulated shareprice, and one which is being shorted, doesn't need much more of a push to scare mum & dad investors into selling?

In a climate of fear and exhaustion (with a SP that is held down for accumulation), all you need to do is blast them with deceptively simple questions like: is this certain?

Listen my friends, nothing is absolutely certain.

Nothing. We operate in a world of relative risk.

The banks could tank in the medium to long term especially with the unemployment figures ticking up. Already they are toppy and overexposed to the domestic housing market. The the bond market is very uncertain. This is context.

Absolute removal of risk as an absurd standard to be using.

THAT is the part of an analysis that is not genuine.

So after watching the SP held down for so long, such holders are not in the mood for risk v reward analysis and you don't give it to them.

It's been many many months now of madamswer's incessant talking the stock down. Still he doesn't hold still he is in here busily blowing the bugle of 'Warning Warning, Danger Will Robinson".

It's a bit overblown don't you think?

The concentration on the SharePrice and only on the idea of total certainty have been relentlessly pursued in here on a daily basis.

They aren't a genuine attempt to come to grips with the relative risk v reward of this company. Let alone the markets involved. The upside is colossal, so it gets ignored.

Does MSB really have the worst risk v reward profile of the entire ASX?

Why doesnt madamswer devote comparable time to others and their lack of certainty?

He has never once compared MSB to any other emerging blue chip biotech stock. We get WOW, we get widgets and we get apples and oranges. Never a comparable stock.

Madamswer has previously noted with satisfaction: it's so easy to disguise accumulation! If Macbank is busy as a broker accumulating shares on behalf of it's many clients, you can be sure they aren't triggering disclosure requirements of the ASX.

As he has pointed out (maybe a bit gleefully?), it's easy to disguise the ultimate beneficial owner of shares being bought.

Indeed.

Something doesn't ring true here. What worries me is mum & dad investors are being scared out of their shares.

IMO they shouldn't be. MSB has the potential to be another CSL and the trajectory to that end is not going to be straightforward, especially in the a market which is almost fanatically obsessed with returns.

IMO investors need to take a deep breath and ask themselves if there aren't wolves in sheeps clothing, not just out there in the market, but also in chat rooms, and they aren't necessarily on on your side.

THAT is why there is a disclaimer when you sign onto HC. You shouldn't rely on posts in here for investing decisions but remain calm and do your own research.

Then go back and take another look at the likelihood that MSB is going to make money in the medium term.

There are some in here who want you to be fearful. Ask yourself if anyone might benefit from that. Because there are buyers out there for your MSB shares.

This is not investment advice. Nobody in here should be pretending to give it either.