Turnbull biographer: sorry I oversold him

Turnbull biographer: sorry I oversold him


Herald Sun
September 18, 2016 9:51am

Paddy Manning is the author of Born to Rule: The unauthorised biography of Malcolm Turnbull. He would like to apologise for exaggerating how good Turnbull would be.
Like millions of Australians, I fear I may have overestimated Malcolm Turnbull...

If I was too kind, it certainly wasn’t for lack of trying ... His low points were covered in detail – his role in the collapse of insurer HIH, often described as his Achilles heel; his morphing of the national broadband network into a multi-technology mix, or MTM, otherwise known as Malcolm Turnbull’s Mess; his relentless undermining of Brendan Nelson.

When the book came out, while others were forecasting Turnbull would now enjoy multiple terms in office,

I wrote that he would need the skills of Houdini to escape his political bind: where the public was behind him, the party wasn’t, and vice versa. Innovation was motherhood, and Turnbull was an elitist who would have trouble thinking outside his Point Piper bubble, trouble understanding the everyday concerns of most Australians. In those heady days of November–December, I may as well have been [p_ssing] in the wind. Now the gale is blowing the other way.

When I’d proposed to call the book Born to Rule, it was not tongue in cheek...

During the federal election campaign ... the title ... rang true ... because it captured Turnbull’s arrogance.

The sales job was beneath him.

A spontaneous wit who could mix it in the pubs was now overscripted and aloof. In the televised debates, Turnbull seemed to imply members of the audience were badly mistaken.

Small-target Turnbull had nothing interesting to say – the agenda was threadbare – and beyond the obvious strain of repeating himself, it seemed he hardly tried.

Instead, he relied on our inevitable good judgement. We were to elect Malcolm Turnbull because he was Malcolm Turnbull.

He would not persuade us. When the verdict came back, too close to call, in his graceless election night performance, Turnbull hid and sulked and even called on the police to investigate. He pointed the finger of blame everywhere but at himself. That’s arrogance. That’s born to rule. That’s Turnbull...

But who could have predicted the combination of gutlessness, vacuity and incompetence that this prime minister has delivered?...

(H)aving scraped over the line at the July election, with barely a mandate, a divided party room, a slim majority and a hostile senate, it is hard to see how Turnbull can or will do anything big. Strange to say, but becoming prime minister may turn out to be the low point in his remarkable life.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/bl...m/news-story/f88e7c068feb80f0de2b679c7b7dd263

What a dud Turnbull is and continues to be, at least we can say he was successful in destroying the Liberal Party and a first term PM, elected in a landslide!