I think this is not a great idea. I welcome a contrary position...

I think this is not a great idea. I welcome a contrary position if it is well researched because I like to consider my position from all angles. FFNZ has at times given some sound arguments for his views although, given the last week or so of action, he is sounding a little jealous at the moment. There are others who are just here out of spite. There are equally just as many who are way over the top in terms of their "positive" posts and I find these just as detrimental to doing any diligent research as the downrampers. So I think all opinions should be welcomed provided they are backed up with reasoned analysis rather than just personal guesses or grudges.