get a load of this, absolutely incredible !! this is a reply from Commsec i received yesterday.
this is what i the great unwashed is up against, no such "rules" apply to hedge funds and their piddly daily hundreds of thousands of "trades" across all listed stocks on the ASX. And may i mention, i would estimate that over the last 3 decades Commsec would have earned well in excess of $100k in commission from me.i until very recently had 4 individual sell order on ADO at prices between 1.4c and 2.1c, they were all bought in the last 6 months, and once i got them i put them in the sell queue for a hopeful day trade, but alas, each time, the ar$se fell out of them, so i "averaged down" as you do. (sh*t happens) So about 2 weeks ago i tried to buy more at James Bond 007 of a cent, and GUESS WHAT ? Commsec blocked me from placing the order, i rang them and they said this activity could be considered MANIPULATIVE !!!!! I then had to remove 2 sell orders so that my buy order could be placed ! So apparently if you buy at different price levels on the way down you are not allowed to have more than 3 orders on, or you are considered a market manipulator ! Here is Commsec's email response to me, i hope big bad ASIC are following me around and reading this, the folks there need to be locked up for allowing "special people" to rort the markets going back DECADES. (oh they have one feather in their cap, they got "Govinda" from Hot Copper a few years ago).
Dear XXXXXX,Thank you for contacting us via phone on 26 May 2025, about your complaint in relation to a recent order on your CommSec trading account ending in XXXX998.Firstly, I would like to apologise for any inconvenience caused by this issue and appreciate you alerting us to it. After careful consideration of the information you provided and the information available in our records, I have concluded your matter is resolved.As a Market Participant, CommSec is committed to ensuring our customers have access to the opportunities available through investing in listed shares, have confidence that the relevant share market will be fair and orderly, and that we comply with the relevant regulations.Market Integrity Rules (MIR)'s play an important role in maintaining investor confidence in Australia's financial markets. These are the rules that regulate what orders CommSec, as a Market Participant, can or cannot accept.To maintain market integrity and market fairness, CommSec and our customers must not place orders that may create a false or misleading appearance of active trading or disrupt the underlying market price of the relevant security (referred to as ‘Market Misconduct'). To help you set up for a successful investing experience, it's important to be across these unacceptable and illegal order / trading practices.With regards to your Sell order for ASX: ADO on 26 May 2025 I can also confirm the ASX Settlement rule 8.10.2, states that a participant must not initiate a transfer of financial products if, by giving effect to that transfer, a CHESS or Issuer Sponsored Holding of less than a Marketable Parcel will result. A marketable parcel, according to ASX, is a holding of shares with a market value of at least $500. For more information about market integrity rules as set out by the ASIC, please visit the ASIC website http://www.asic.gov.au/regulatory-resources/markets/market-integrity-rules/ I would like to extend my apologies for any inconvenience caused by the issue. We value your feedback as we continue to review our business processes, ensuring our customers are receiving the best possible experience.I have now closed the complaint however I remain committed to assisting you, please get in touch if you require any further assistance.Your optionsThere is nothing further you need to do if you are satisfied with the outcome.If you are not satisfied with the outcome of our investigation you can: Contact our Commonwealth Bank Complaints team Write to: CBA Group Customer Relations, Reply Paid 41, Sydney NSW 2001 www.asic.gov.au
Expand