Victoria On Road To Nowhere - $12.7b Cost Blow Out

  1. 12,391 Posts.
    lightbulb Created with Sketch. 1313
    Victoria has been subject to further mismangement and incompetence by this foul Labor government lead by Andrews/Allan and Pallas.

    Since 31st Dec'23 infrastructure costs have blown out by another $12.7b according to a Herald Sun analysis of the federal budget.

    What is even more galling is thaese cost overruns were not in the final Vic budget handed down by Tim Pallas just a week before the federal buget was issued. Pallas would have known about these costs but chose to con Victoria and not include them in the budget.

    What is even more of a concern is that many large projects like The North East Link has been converted into a cost plus project where all the risks have been transferred to the victorian taxpayer.

    Labor incompetence grows by the week. Allan and Pallas should resign.
    ****************************************************************************
    Victorian infrastructure project costs have skyrocketed by $12.7bn

    Dozens of Big Build infrastructure projects have blown out yet again in budget overruns, costing taxpayers a hefty $83.6m every single day. See the full list here.
    Jade Gailberger and Matt Johnston

    June 3, 2024 - 5:00AM

    606 comments



    Victoria's financial situation 'not looking good' amid 'massive' debt




    Road and rail project budgets across Victoria have blown out by an eye-watering $12.7bn since December – costing taxpayers an extra $83.6m a day.

    The expected costs of 28 joint state and commonwealth projects have risen in the past six months, figures produced during parliamentary hearings on the federal budget show.

    This includes three regional rail upgrades, a suite of suburban roads projects, the state’s most expensive toll road the North East Link, and major highway interchanges.

    A Herald Sun analysis of the commonwealth’s Infrastructure Investment Program – which lists all jointly-funded projects – shows the federal government has injected an extra $5bn into Victoria’s major builds to ensure works are completed.


    Road and rail projects have blown out. Picture: David Crosling

    The biggest blowout was the North East Link, which Premier Jacinta Allan revealed last year would now cost up to $26.1bn, up from $15.8bn.

    But a further $2.4bn worth of overruns since a December 13 budget update was released by Treasurer Jim Chalmers – about $15.8m a day – were also revealed in the documents.
    Most were not included in the state budget, released a week before the federal one.

    Federal Infrastructure Minister Catherine King blamed the taxpayer-funded pain on global supply chain constraints and labour shortages, but opposition infrastructure spokeswoman Bridget McKenzie said the new spending was to “pay off Jacinta Allan’s infrastructure credit card”.


    The federal government has injected an extra $5bn into Victoria’s major builds to ensure works are completed. Picture: Andrew Henshaw

    One of the biggest budget blowouts was for upgrading suburban roads in Melbourne’s north and southeast, which will now cost $3.1bn – an increase of $874.5m.

    The Camerons Lane interchange on the Hume Freeway, a key route for freight transport using the Beveridge precinct, has also blown out from $300m to more than $1bn.

    The federal share of the payment for that project also increased dramatically, from 50 per cent to 86 per cent.
    The Gippsland Rail Line upgrade which includes new signalling equipment and station works has ballooned by $345.3m to $878.1bn, prompting a $290.1m federal cash injection.

    The North East Link is set to cost up to $26.1bn, up from the earlier budget estimate of $15.8bn.

    A spokeswoman for minister King said the federal government wanted the projects delivered and had worked constructively with states and territories in the lead up to last month’s budget to identify funding priorities.
    “Through the 2024-25 budget, we invested additional funding in a range of existing projects across the country to ensure they could be delivered,” she said.
    “The construction sector has been affected by cost increases, supply-chain constraints and labour shortages, challenges being experienced by industry globally.”

    Some of the $5bn in extra federal funding was redirected from projects dumped following a contentious review of federally-funded infrastructure, such as a Geelong fast rail project.
    Twelve Victorian infrastructure projects were among 50 projects axed by Canberra to claw back $7bn.
    But Ms McKenzie said $4.5bn of the $5bn was just to pay off Jacinta Allan’s infrastructure credit card, with not one additional kilometre of road built for the money.
    “The only way to describe the infrastructure spend is throwing money at Victorian Labor to cover their cost blowouts and debts,” Senator McKenzie said.

    Geelong fast rail was one of the dumped projects. Picture: David Crosling

    The figures have exposed a series of cost blowouts on the $4bn Regional Rail Revival, which was a joint federal-state program to upgrade every country railway line in Victoria. As revealed by the Herald Sun in March, the program veered off track, with delays on the Warrnambool, Gippsland and Shepparton line upgrades due to labour and material shortages and signalling problems.

    As well as the Gippsland line upgrade blowout, the commonwealth documents show the Shepparton line stage three upgrade will cost an extra $14m, and South Geelong to Waurn Ponds upgrades are $41m higher.
    The state budget did not reveal these new estimates, and listed completion dates as to be confirmed.
    A Victorian government spokesman said the state budget was published before the commonwealth budget so the extra investment was not known at that time.

    But Victorian opposition transport infrastructure spokesman David Southwick said the Allan government had been caught cooking the books to cover up its financial mismanagement.
    “Every time projects blow out, it means taxpayers end up footing the bill and missing out vital services,” Mr Southwick said.
    “Labor needs to come clean and release the true costings for each of these projects.”
    VICTORIA'S BALLOONING BIG BUILD BUILD
    Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4
    0 Project Name Initial Cost Final Cost Difference
    1 Ballarat intermodal freight hub $9.1m $55.5m $46.4m
    2 Ballarat to Ouyen (Birchip Rainbow Rd, McLoughlans Rd intersection upgrade) $2.4m $3.3m $900,000
    3 Bannockburn entrance township safety project $3.2m $4.1m $900,000
    4 Camerons Lane interchange $300m $1.05b $750m
    5 Clyde Rd upgrade $250m $277.7m $27.7m
    6 Commuter car park upgrade (Frankston) $87m $88.2m $1.2m
    7 Commuter car park upgrades (Northern lines) $140m $178.3m $38.3m
    8 Commuter car park upgrades (Ringwood) $29.7m $33.2m $3.5m
    9 Geelong-Portarlington-Wilsons Rd intersection upgrade $5m $6.5m $1.5m
    Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4
    0 Gippsland rail line upgrade $538.2m $878.1m $345.3m
    1 Glenelg Hwy and Eurambeen-Streatham Rd intersection upgrade $3m $5m $2m
    2 Grubb Rd, Ocean Grove upgrade $5m $7.7m $2.7m
    3 Maroondah Hwy and Bellara Dr intersection upgrade $10m $12.7m $2.7m
    4 Midland Link Hwy, Midland Hwy to Magills Lane safety improvement $4m $4.8m $800,000
    5 Murray Basin Freight rail project (off-network) $466.5m $645.7m $179.2m
    6 North East Link $15.8bn $26.1bn $10.3bn
    7 North East rail line supporting infrastructure $10m $10.9m $900,000
    8 Pakenham roads upgrade $391.5m $415.7m $24.2m
    9 Princes Hwy East (duplication between Traralgon and Sale) $253.3m $292.2m $38.9m
    Column 1 Column 2 Column 3 Column 4
    0 Shepparton rail line upgrade (stage 3) $400m $414.2m $14.2m
    1 South Geelong to Waurn Ponds duplication $893m $933.6m $40.6m
    2 Suburban Road upgrades (south eastern and rorthern roads) $2.27b $3.14b $874.5m
    3 Surf Coast Hwy, Reserve Rd, Felix St intersection improvement $3.8m $5m $1.2m
    4 Thompson Rd, North Geelong $4.6m $5m $400,000
    5 Various rural intersection upgrades $20m $23.4m $3.4m
    6 Western Fwy realignment at Pykes Creek (Ballarat Bound) $13.5m $21m $7.5m
    7 Western Highway $1.34b $1.35b $11.8m
    8 TOTAL     $12.72B


 
arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch. arrow-down-2 Created with Sketch.