Tinnitus quite right .When you look at Flannery(palaeontology /zoology)Steffens (chem. eng.) they obviously dont have the climate change training ( physics, meteorology astro physics etc) and should not have been picked to head up the climate change commission.However thir alarmist statements at appropriate times have well backed up Gillard`s carbon tax as required. As for age older people have seen cycles come and go and are quicker to pick up government and other scams.