Well, for each their own, I suppose. In 2015, short term impatient 'investors' complained about Intelligent Investor's S32 recommendation (dropping from $1.5 to $0.9). None of them complained when S32 is priced at $3 to $3.5 today.
II on average get 60% of their buy recommendation right, so 40% error - that's why you have maximum weighting limits. A well-balanced portfolio is a must if you want to make money in the market over long term. Average holding period for their recommendation is 4 years. Not for short term pump and dump traders.
Paul Clitheroe joined Eureka Report, not II.
And as to paying $700 a year, I am fine with it. Their tips on DHG last month earned me 3 years subscription fee in less than 1 week, so anything extra is just a bonus.
TGA Price at posting:
77.5¢ Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held