i think his system has merit in that using calculations you can...

i think his system has merit in that using calculations you can work out the value of a company but I think it really is very difficult to predict the future. Often the most accurate indicator of the future is past performance - MCE doesn't have the history, BHP and CBA does. These companies also have money coming in from various angles.

past performance over 5 + years must be a big part of rating any company - this doesn't seem to be the case with roger's A1 system -soon as a company starts going well over a year or so it suddenly shoots from a B3 to A1 - too quick in my opinion

Would you hold more of MCE than BHP or CBA in today's climate? I bought MCE because I liked the sector and i think the company has a good future. I didn't buy it because roger said it was an A1.

So, no I don't rate his system