What's spooking graphite stocks, page-9

Hi Tobyjack,

Your proposition is that MNS is subject to the wider graphite market. My point is that apparently MNS has a unique product and should not be subject to the same market forces as other graphite companies.

For instance, some say that KNL and SYR are simply refractory graphite companies.

MNS, on the other hand, is apparently a company with a unique resource and unique technology that produces clean, green graphite.

My posts are well within the topic you have mentioned in the title to the thread, although I must say that I have never really seen a topic thread have much sway in what is posted, notwithstanding my gratuitous adherence to the thread topic.

Now that we have established that we are on the same page, I wonder whether you could confirm your viewpoint (at a fundamental, technical and/or geological level) whether you think MNS is subject to the same market forces as other graphite companies listed on the ASX?

If so, have you always held this belief?