I've been wondering just what Donny could do to get the magic...

I've been wondering just what Donny could do to get the magic back -- get shot again -------- clearly

but, where - where could long don get shot and it not be so bloody fast to heal -

so, it could be a constant reminder to his flock that - 'I got shot twice you know, first time, there was blood everywhere, god saved me' But it healed quickly.
'Second time, I got hit in the bonespur and it's given me a permanent limp'

as Donny limps onto the stage at every outdoor rally - walking on like Long John Silver