Australia's largest stock trading and investment forum Australia's #1 stock forum

IMU

2.83%

5.2¢ imugene limited

Yes he's having a go . No certainty in this world This is a...

First 24566 Last

Share
Profile

Follow
valueadd

5,642 Posts.

1772

11/06/24

15:02

Post #: 74261007
Share

Originally posted by StrayCatBlues ↑

Mason might indeed be full of it but there’s a lot of playing the man when he posts. Everyone is very eager to attack him, his motivations, his occupation etc but I haven’t seen anyone make any genuine attempt to engage with his statistical analysis or try to debunk it.

Now if your response to that is why would anyone bother, that’s probably fair. It likely is a waste of time engaging with someone who isn’t an oncologist and has no direct involvement with the progress of IMU trials. But people here are often saying “DYOR” and “trust the science” - here’s a bloke actually doing his own research (and has clearly done a lot of his own thinking about cancer treatments generally) and coming at things from a scientific analysis angle, and no one wants to (or can) engage with it.

99% of the posters here wouldn’t have the first clue what he’s talking about (I include myself in that group) and don’t have the background or ability to properly consider it, but that doesn’t make it an invalid or useless contribution to the discussion here. He might have been wrong on RAC (I don’t know), he might have questionable motivations (I don’t know, but I don’t think that’s a given just because he criticises IMU’s therapies) but he has attempted to dissect IMU’s prospects in a more thorough and scientific way than anyone else on these forums.

Yes, maybe his “science” is flawed, or he’s omitting things, or it’s based on incomplete data (of course it is and he acknowledges that) but is that worse than the many posters here who just post that they “believe in the science”, whatever that means? How many of those people have asked themselves why they believe in the science? Is it because the company says it’s great science, because they are regurgitating what other posters on here say? It’s certainly not because of their own rigorous research or analysis. There’s nothing wrong with that - investing in biotechs isn’t just reserved for scientists - but Mason at least presents his case for why he doesn’t believe in the science.

AIcp likes to repeat that Mason thought the CR was an “excellent result”, as if that acknowledgement invalidates the rest of his opinions. Yes, the CR is a great result, but it is one result in one trial. It does not make a company. At this point it’s statistically insignificant….how are the other patients going, what updates are we going to get? We don’t know….but it seems that a lot of people (and maybe the company itself, judging by its prominence in anns/presentations) are hanging a lot of hats on that CR. Hopefully we will get more excellent results but let’s not pretend one CR is job done.

Expand

Yes he's having a go .
No certainty in this world
This is a forum ....
At the end of the day
Who's right ... who's wrong
Most of us r pricks when it
comes down to it .
Some bigger than others

IMU Price at posting: 6.0¢ Sentiment: Buy Disclosure: Held
5 Upvote

1 Great analysis

Reply

Top Stories

KGL

KGL sniffs 19% Cu from drilling at Rockface play in NT

The Big Deal: Free-to-air TV swings the axe, but will it be enough as enormous sports deal bills loom?

RHI

Red Hill Minerals Signs $6.5 Million Agreement with Peel Mining to Explore Curnamona Project, NSW

TVN

Tivan and EARTH AI gear up to commence fresh drilling at Sandover lead-silver project, NT

CUV

British study shows Clinuvel drug effective on DNA of UV-damaged skin

There are more pages in this discussion • 791 more messages in this thread...

First 24566 Last

Add IMU (ASX) to my watchlist

(20min delay)
Last 5.2¢		Change -0.002(2.83%)		Mkt cap ! $380.6M

Open	High	Low	Value	Volume
5.2¢	5.2¢	5.1¢	$338.0K	6.569M

Buyers (Bids)

No.	Vol.	Price($)
38	1561263	5.1¢

Sellers (Offers)

Price($)	Vol.	No.
5.2¢	2015612	17

View Market Depth

No.	Vol.	Price($)
40	1569305	0.051
44	2602102	0.050
31	4012277	0.049
19	1376988	0.048
13	1191292	0.047

Price($)	Vol.	No.
0.052	2015612	17
0.053	1208415	10
0.054	1364393	6
0.055	1727924	14
0.056	753333	5

Last trade - 13.27pm 05/07/2024 (20 minute delay)

IMU (ASX) Chart

Yes he's having a go . No certainty in this world This is a...

KGL sniffs 19% Cu from drilling at Rockface play in NT

The Big Deal: Free-to-air TV swings the axe, but will it be enough as enormous sports deal bills loom?

Red Hill Minerals Signs $6.5 Million Agreement with Peel Mining to Explore Curnamona Project, NSW

Tivan and EARTH AI gear up to commence fresh drilling at Sandover lead-silver project, NT

British study shows Clinuvel drug effective on DNA of UV-damaged skin

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News

Yes he's having a go . No certainty in this world This is a...

Top Stories

KGL sniffs 19% Cu from drilling at Rockface play in NT

The Big Deal: Free-to-air TV swings the axe, but will it be enough as enormous sports deal bills loom?

Red Hill Minerals Signs $6.5 Million Agreement with Peel Mining to Explore Curnamona Project, NSW

Tivan and EARTH AI gear up to commence fresh drilling at Sandover lead-silver project, NT

British study shows Clinuvel drug effective on DNA of UV-damaged skin

Featured News

Buyers (Bids)

Sellers (Offers)

Featured News